This analytical article by Snizhana Vasylieva, lawyer at ALARIUS Law Firm and postgraduate student at the Institute of Law of Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv, prepared for the “Yurydychnyy Bulletin of Ukraine”, provides a comprehensive examination of the legal regime and cadastral classification challenges concerning the lands of wholesale agricultural markets (ORSGP).
Below is the professionally formatted, publication-ready version of the material, structured for optimal readability across legal media platforms:
Legal Status and Target Purpose Criteria for Lands of Wholesale Markets of Agricultural Products
By Snizhana Vasylieva
Lawyer at ALARIUS Bar Association, Postgraduate Student at the Institute of Law of Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv
The wholesale market of agricultural products (ORSGP) serves as a critical infrastructural "node" of the agrarian market, designed to ensure the wholesale circulation of goods, market concentration, and the reduction of logistical losses. This directly aligns with the objectives enshrined in the Law of Ukraine "On Wholesale Markets of Agricultural Products", specifically accelerating the transit of produce from producers to final consumers.
Amid wartime conditions—characterized by disrupted supply chains, shifting production and consumption geographies, and localized destruction—the stability of these infrastructural nodes depends heavily on the legal certainty governing their land resources. However, the legislative framework governing ORSGP land status remains fragmentary. While the specialized law addresses land aspects only abstractly via Article 12 (referencing an "order defined by law"), the Land Code of Ukraine (LC of Ukraine) establishes no bespoke circulation rules for wholesale agricultural market lands.
These regulatory gaps frequently trigger disputes and attract scrutiny from law enforcement agencies, risking the suspension of commercial operations. A primary catalyst for such disputes is the complex determination of a land plot's target purpose.
The Legal Framework of Land Purpose and "Types of Use"
Complying with the designated purpose of land is a strict statutory obligation for landowners and users. Under Articles 19 and 20 of the LC of Ukraine, the legal regime of a land category is decisive in evaluating whether land use is targeted or non-target. Within each category, specific codes are formalized under the Classifier of Types of Target Purpose of Land Plots (KVTsPZ).
In practice, a narrower concept—the "type of use" (the specific functional phrasing in managerial allocation decisions)—is frequently applied. While changing a land category or target purpose code requires a formal, approved land management project, altering only the specific type of use without changing the land category does not require a separate project under current legislation (as affirmed by the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court on June 1, 2021, in case No. 925/929/19). Furthermore, while the current LC of Ukraine omits the term "type of use," agricultural lands remain subject to strict statutory boundaries under Articles 31–37 of the code.
Key Criteria for Determining the Correct Target Purpose Code
Because a land plot's target purpose code is derived from its formation materials and the organizing authority's decision, administrative and judicial authorities evaluate specific evidentiary layers:
1. Land Plot Formation Materials and Title Documents as Primary Sources
Courts and regulatory bodies investigate the designated purpose embedded within:
- Managing body decisions regarding the allocation, withdrawal, or transfer of state/communal land;
- Land management documentation (land management projects, technical documentation);
- Historical extracts from the State Land Cadastre (SLC) and primary title documents predating property acquisition.
- judicial precedent:* In its ruling of April 3, 2025, in case No. 600/5817/21-a, the Supreme Court emphasized that determining a plot's target purpose during formation is the responsibility of the land management documentation developer.
2. SLC Information as an Official, but Refutable "Source"
The Administrative Court of Cassation (e.g., in case No. 120/5760/21-a) has affirmed that SLC entries rely on submitted land management documentation. However, as established in case No. 400/4165/21, SLC data carries a refutable presumption of reliability.
To challenge or verify inaccurate SLC information, practitioners utilize specific evidentiary tools:
- Forensic Expert Opinions: Essential for resolving disputes regarding turning point coordinates, boundary overlaps, quantitative discrepancies, or geodata technical errors.
- Primary Land Management Documentation: Original diversion projects, technical documentation, coordinate catalogs, field measurement logs, XML exchange files, and boundary agreement acts.
- Title Documents: Historical allocation decisions, old-style state acts, lease/superficies/emphiteusis agreements, and court rulings confirming legal regimes.
- Topographic and Geodetic Data: Boundary demarcation acts, certified surveyor reports, coordinate schemes, and comparative overlay plans.
- Town-Planning Documentation: Land inventories, settlement boundary formations, and approved master plans or zoning schemes.
Administrative Correction of SLC Errors
When no active litigation exists, Ukrainian law permits a streamlined administrative procedure for correcting SLC errors via the state cadastral registrar. Errors are categorized into:
- Technical Errors: Discrepancies where correct source data is supported by documents but displayed inaccurately in the cadastre.
- Primary Documentation Errors: Inaccuracies embedded within the original land management documentation, requiring prior correction of the underlying documentation before updating the SLC.
Required Documentation Package:
- Application/notification formatted per SLC maintenance rules;
- Documents unequivocally confirming correct data (managerial decisions, proper land documentation, or court rulings);
- Updated land management documentation (if the error originated at the documentation stage).
Conclusion
Ensuring the legal certainty of land use for agricultural wholesale markets requires an integrated approach: relying on primary formation materials, verifying SLC data consistency against urban planning standards, deploying robust forensic and documentary evidence strategies, and utilizing administrative error-correction mechanisms when discrepancies arise.
Other news
More news
.jpg)














.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)














.jpg)





























.jpg)



